Richmond residents oppose three-story home proposal on Princess Anne Street

In a virtual meeting held on April 22, 2025, the Richmond City Commission of Architectural Review engaged in a spirited discussion regarding a proposed three-story single-family home at 1922 Princess Anne Avenue. The meeting, attended by city officials and concerned residents, highlighted the delicate balance between new development and preserving the historical character of the neighborhood.

The applicant, John Carlos, presented plans for the new dwelling, which he described as inspired by the architectural style of a nearby building at 1900 Princess Anne. He emphasized that the structure would include front and rear porches, along with a balcony, aiming to blend with the existing aesthetic of the area. However, the proposal sparked significant concern among local residents, particularly from Johnny Walker, a lifelong Richmond citizen whose family has deep roots in the neighborhood.

Walker passionately voiced his apprehensions about the impact of a three-story home on a block characterized by historic, two-story houses built in the early 1900s. He argued that such a structure would disrupt the architectural harmony of the area, which he described as a beautiful and cohesive community. Walker's remarks were underscored by a personal connection to the neighborhood, as he recounted his family's long-standing ties and the historical significance of the street, once known as Undertaker Road.

The discussion revealed a broader tension between development and preservation in Richmond. Residents expressed a desire for the commission to consider the neighborhood's historical context when evaluating new projects. Walker noted that while the commission may not have the authority to outright reject the construction, they could influence the design to ensure it aligns with the existing architectural landscape.

As the meeting progressed, it became clear that the community's voice would play a crucial role in shaping the future of Princess Anne Avenue. The commission's deliberations will not only determine the fate of the proposed home but also reflect the ongoing dialogue about how Richmond can honor its past while accommodating growth. The outcome remains to be seen, but the commitment of residents like Walker to advocate for their neighborhood underscores the importance of community engagement in urban development.