Colorado Public Utilities Commission hears case against EA Towing's owner Elias Arana

The evidentiary hearing for case 24G-0535TO, involving the Public Utilities Commission of Colorado versus EA Towing, Inc., commenced on April 22, 2025, at 9 AM. The hearing was presided over by Administrative Law Judge Robert Garvey, who began by confirming the presence of the involved parties.

The hearing featured Assistant Attorneys General Aileen Chong and Justin Larson representing the trial staff, alongside investigators Joe Potts and Lloyd Swin. Elias Arana, the sole proprietor of EA Towing, appeared without legal counsel, stating he was unable to secure representation for the case.

Judge Garvey initiated the proceedings by addressing preliminary matters, including a motion to amend a previous filing related to alleged violations against EA Towing. The judge clarified that the amendment involved changing a subsection of the violation, which Arana opposed but expressed uncertainty regarding the implications of the motion.

As the hearing progressed, Judge Garvey noted that Arana had not submitted any exhibits for the hearing, which was a requirement discussed in a prior prehearing conference. Arana acknowledged this oversight, indicating that he had relied on an email regarding a tow bill as his primary evidence.

The judge provided a brief overview of the hearing procedures, emphasizing that the staff would present their case, including witness examinations and the introduction of exhibits. He advised Arana on how to raise objections to the exhibits, clarifying that objections must be based on legal grounds rather than personal opinions about their relevance.

Technical difficulties arose when Arana reported a black screen on his video feed, which hindered his ability to see the proceedings. Judge Garvey suggested that he exit and re-enter the virtual meeting to resolve the issue.

The hearing continued with the judge ensuring that all parties understood the process and their roles, setting the stage for the presentation of evidence and testimonies in the case against EA Towing. The session highlighted the challenges faced by individuals representing themselves in legal proceedings, particularly in navigating procedural requirements and technical issues.