Newburyport Council debates outdoor dining plan amid bench removal concerns

The Newburyport City Council convened on April 22, 2025, to discuss a contentious outdoor dining application that has sparked significant debate among council members and residents alike. The proposal, which seeks to establish outdoor dining in Market Square, has raised concerns about the impact on public space and the fate of memorial benches previously removed from the area.

The council's discussion began with a vote to approve the outdoor dining application, which was contingent upon the Parks Commission's approval. While the commission had given its nod, Councilor Donohue expressed strong reservations, citing the emotional distress caused to families who had dedicated benches that were removed and not replaced. He argued that the outdoor dining setup would encroach on Market Square, a space meant for public enjoyment and transit.

Councilor Preston clarified that the property owner, LaRosa's, would be managing the outdoor dining space, and emphasized the need for a compromise that would allow both the return of the benches and the establishment of outdoor dining. He noted that the benches were removed to facilitate outdoor dining during the pandemic, but their absence has left a noticeable gap in the square.

The council members debated various solutions, including moving the benches slightly forward to accommodate dining space while preserving the integrity of Market Square. However, many councilors voiced their preference for keeping the benches in their original locations, arguing that the square should remain a transitory area for pedestrians rather than a dining venue.

As discussions progressed, a motion was proposed to amend the outdoor dining plan, reducing the square footage allocated for dining from 600 to 300 square feet. This amendment aimed to strike a balance between the needs of the restaurant and the preservation of public space. While some councilors supported this compromise, others remained skeptical, fearing it would still detract from the square's intended use.

The meeting highlighted the ongoing tension between business interests and community values in Newburyport. As the council continues to navigate these discussions, the fate of the memorial benches and the character of Market Square remain at the forefront of community concerns. The council's next steps will be crucial in determining how to balance the needs of local businesses with the preservation of public spaces that residents cherish.