City Board approves Chick-fil-A plans with conditions on signage and design

The Winter Springs Planning and Zoning Board convened for a special meeting on April 24, 2025, primarily to discuss the proposed Chick-fil-A development. The meeting began with public input, where David Amstra from Pegasus Engineering addressed concerns regarding a failed pond at Tuscariella Crossings. He clarified that the failure was due to a construction defect rather than stormwater issues, assuring that the new development would not adversely affect the city's stormwater system.

Following public comments, the board reviewed various aspects of the Chick-fil-A proposal, including site circulation, window placements, and signage. Board members expressed concerns about the design elements, particularly the window sizes on the facade facing State Road 434, and the need for aesthetic consistency across the building. The discussion also touched on the monument sign, with suggestions to consolidate from two signs to one.

A motion was made to recommend approval of the Chick-fil-A project with specific conditions, including the review of brick color, window sizes, and the consolidation of the monument sign. After some deliberation, the board agreed to revise the motion to streamline the recommendations, focusing on the essential design elements while allowing city staff to address operational concerns regarding delivery vehicle access.

The revised motion passed unanimously, signaling the board's support for the project with the outlined conditions. The meeting concluded with no further agenda items, and the board prepared for the next regular meeting, where additional public input would be welcomed.