Elgin Police recover Karen Shepherd's remains after 42 years with cold case unit

In a poignant session on April 23, 2025, the Elgin City Council recognized the significant achievements of the Elgin Police Department's cold case unit, particularly in the resolution of the long-standing case of Karen Shepherd. This meeting highlighted the department's innovative approach and community collaboration that ultimately led to the recovery of Shepherd's vehicle and the identification of her remains, providing closure to her family after 42 years of uncertainty.

The cold case unit, established in May 2024 under Chief Lolly's leadership, has dedicated resources to unsolved cases, demonstrating exceptional investigative skills. Detectives Andrew Hooten and Matt Vartanian led the efforts to reopen Shepherd's case, utilizing modern forensic techniques and public engagement strategies, including a podcast titled "Somebody Knows Something," which helped generate new leads.

On March 24, 2025, a sonar search of the Fox River, conducted in partnership with Chaos Divers, resulted in the discovery of Shepherd's vehicle. The vehicle was recovered the following day, and human remains were positively identified as belonging to Shepherd on March 27, 2025. This breakthrough was celebrated as a historic resolution, made possible through the collaborative efforts of various community partners, including the Kane County coroner's office and local towing services.

During the meeting, Mayor David Captain proclaimed a day of remembrance for Karen Shepherd, acknowledging the tireless work of the cold case unit that brought resolution and peace to a case that had remained silent for far too long. Chief Lolly expressed gratitude for the community's support and emphasized the importance of collaboration in achieving such outcomes. Detectives Hooten and Vartanian echoed these sentiments, highlighting the emotional impact of the case and the dedication of all involved in bringing closure to Shepherd's family.

The council's recognition of the cold case unit not only underscores the importance of addressing unresolved cases but also reflects a broader commitment to community safety and justice. As the Elgin Police Department continues to innovate and engage with the public, the resolution of Karen Shepherd's case serves as a powerful reminder of the potential for healing and closure in the face of long-standing tragedies.