Design team seeks feedback on new downtown College Town residential project

The Ithaca City Planning and Development Board convened on April 22, 2025, to discuss a proposed housing project that aims to enhance the downtown area and provide much-needed residential options. The meeting highlighted the project's potential benefits, including stunning views of the gorge and proximity to local amenities, which were emphasized by the project developers.

During the session, board members provided feedback on the design and architectural elements of the proposed building. Concerns were raised regarding how the new structure would fit within the existing neighborhood's character. One board member noted the importance of maintaining historical continuity and questioned whether the building's exterior would align with the broader aesthetic of the area. This sentiment was echoed by others who expressed a desire for the design to reflect the neighborhood's historical context while also incorporating modern elements.

Material choices for the building were a significant topic of discussion. Developers indicated that they had not yet finalized materials but were considering options such as metal panels and masonry. Board members stressed the importance of selecting materials that would harmonize with the surrounding architecture, with some advocating for a more textured approach rather than a flat appearance.

The concept of the building's massing was also scrutinized. Several members suggested that the design could benefit from clearer architectural distinctions between different sections of the building to enhance its visual appeal. The idea of a "pinwheel" layout was discussed, with board members encouraging the developers to ensure that this concept is effectively communicated in the building's design.

In addition to architectural considerations, the meeting touched on practical aspects such as the building's entrance and visibility from the street. Suggestions included improving signage and possibly adding awning elements to make the entrance more inviting and recognizable.

Overall, the meeting underscored the collaborative nature of the planning process, with board members actively engaging with developers to refine the project. As the developers continue to gather feedback and finalize their plans, the board's insights will play a crucial role in shaping a development that meets both community needs and aesthetic standards. The next steps will involve further technical documentation and revisions based on the feedback received, ensuring that the project aligns with the city's vision for growth and development.