New York lawmakers discuss mattress EPR bill amid industry fee opposition

The New York State Senate convened on April 28, 2025, to discuss significant amendments to the Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) program, particularly focusing on mattress disposal. A key point of contention was the proposal for retailers to collect a program fee established by a producer responsibility organization, which has been a topic of ongoing debate for several years.

Senators expressed concerns about the implications of imposing a fixed fee on consumers. One senator highlighted that without this fee, the bill could face challenges in passing, emphasizing the importance of moving forward with the current legislation. The discussion included references to successful models in four other states, which have implemented similar programs, but the New York bill aims to avoid imposing direct costs on consumers.

The mattress industry has voiced opposition to the bill, particularly regarding the fee structure. Senators discussed the impact of foreign mattress imports and the federal government's efforts to combat unfair trade practices through tariffs. However, the bill's sponsor clarified that the legislation is not designed to address international trade disputes but rather to regulate mattress disposal within New York.

Concerns were raised about compliance, especially regarding online sales of mattresses. The sponsor assured that the bill would require manufacturers to register their brands with the Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) to sell legally in New York. This registration process is intended to ensure that all mattresses sold in the state meet the program's requirements.

In conclusion, the Senate's discussions reflect a balancing act between environmental responsibility and consumer costs. The bill aims to enhance mattress recycling and disposal while navigating the complexities of industry compliance and international trade issues. The outcome of this legislation could set a precedent for future EPR initiatives in New York.