Commissioners approve fire-safe development despite design concerns at design review meeting

The Coconino County Planning and Zoning Commission held a study session and public hearing on March 26, 2025, to discuss a proposed development project. The meeting featured a range of opinions from commissioners regarding the design and safety features of the project.

The discussion began with Commissioner Short acknowledging the design review overlay zone definitions, although he noted that not all paragraphs were included in the proposal. Concerns were raised by another commissioner about the visual impact of the proposed structures, which were described as "boxes on stilts." This commissioner emphasized that the existing design review guidelines call for structures to blend with natural features and avoid boxy appearances. He expressed that the proposed designs did not align with these principles, suggesting they would not harmonize with the organic environment.

In contrast, several other commissioners expressed support for the project. Commissioner Walsh highlighted the safety improvements offered by the use of fire-resistant materials, indicating that these enhancements would benefit the property. Commissioner Williams also approved of the design, stating that the aesthetic was appealing and that it was unnecessary to delay the project for potential future changes to the design review guidelines. Similarly, Commissioner Berger acknowledged the improvements in fire safety, despite personal reservations about the design, and emphasized the importance of not hindering safety advancements. Commissioner Leslie echoed this sentiment, supporting the project based on its fire safety features.

Overall, the meeting showcased a divide among commissioners, with some prioritizing adherence to design aesthetics while others focused on safety improvements. The commission's discussions reflect ongoing considerations in balancing design integrity with practical safety needs in Coconino County.