Yarmouth Port committee approves demolition and new home construction at Wharf Lane

In a pivotal meeting on April 28, 2025, the Town of Yarmouth's Old Kings Highway Historic District Committee approved the demolition of a historic cottage on Wharf Lane, a decision that has sparked significant discussion among community members. The cottage, one of only three antique structures remaining in the area, has been a point of contention as the neighborhood evolves.

Committee members expressed their sadness over the loss of the quaint cottage, emphasizing its unique character and historical significance. One member noted, "It's a shame to see it go," highlighting the cottage's charm amidst a backdrop of increasingly imposing homes. The owners, Richard and Cindy Schickler, shared their struggles with the small size of the cottage, which they purchased in 2008. They explained that as their family has grown, the need for a more practical living space has become essential.

Despite the emotional weight of the decision, the committee ultimately agreed that the new construction planned for the site would better align with the current character of the neighborhood. "Time marches on," one member remarked, underscoring the need to adapt to changing community dynamics. The committee's approval signals a shift in the landscape of Wharf Lane, as the town balances preservation with the practical needs of its residents.

As Yarmouth continues to develop, the fate of its historic structures remains a critical topic, with community members keenly aware of the implications for their neighborhoods. The Schicklers' plans for a new single-family dwelling will now move forward, marking a new chapter for Wharf Lane.