Queens Manor residents debate special exception permit for short-term rental

The Board of Zoning Appeals Hearing on April 28, 2025, in Carmel, Indiana, focused on a petition for a special exception permit for short-term residential rental submitted by local residents, the Gordons. The meeting began with the Gordons presenting their case, highlighting their extensive involvement in the Queens Manor community over the past few years. The Gordons emphasized their commitment to improving neighborhood safety and fostering community spirit, citing their efforts in organizing security measures and community events.

The Gordons argued that their request for a permit to occasionally host guests in their semi-detached apartment should not raise concerns about a potential influx of similar applications in the area. They reassured the council that their property is unique and not comparable to more densely populated areas where short-term rentals are common. They also noted that most of their guests would be acquaintances, and they would implement thorough vetting processes to ensure safety.

Following the Gordons' presentation, several residents expressed opposition to the permit. Sue McGill, a long-time resident of Queens Manor, articulated concerns about the potential disruption to the neighborhood's tranquility and stability. She emphasized the community's long-standing tradition of maintaining a peaceful environment, supported by informal agreements among neighbors rather than formal regulations. McGill highlighted the importance of preserving the character of the neighborhood, which has remained largely unchanged for decades.

The council allowed for public comments, with three residents opposing the permit, each given five minutes to voice their concerns. The discussions underscored a divide between the Gordons' vision for their property and the apprehensions of some neighbors regarding the implications of short-term rentals on community dynamics.

As the meeting concluded, the council was tasked with considering the arguments presented by both sides. The outcome of the hearing will determine whether the Gordons will be granted the special exception permit, which could set a precedent for future applications in the area. The council's decision is anticipated to reflect the balance between individual property rights and the collective interests of the community.