Developers present updated design for 30 Caroline near historic Sperry's restaurant

During the recent Design Review Commission meeting on April 30, 2025, discussions centered around a proposed development adjacent to the historic Sperry's restaurant, now referred to as 30 Caroline. The project aims to construct a new building that steps back from the facade of the existing structure, addressing concerns about maintaining the historic character of the area.

The developers presented a revised design that includes a third floor stepping back from the Sperry's facade, which they believe will help preserve the visual integrity of the historic site. They emphasized that the new building would not be structurally attached to Sperry's, ensuring that if the new construction were ever removed, the historic restaurant would remain intact.

However, the proposal has faced opposition from local preservation groups, with many residents expressing concerns about the design's compatibility with the historic district. Letters submitted to the commission highlighted fears that the new building could alter the character of the area, which many consider a Saratoga tradition. The developers acknowledged these concerns but pointed out that the site is not designated as a historic district, which allows for more flexibility in design.

In response to feedback from previous meetings, the developers made several adjustments to the design, including changes to the materials and colors used. They proposed using lighter shades of brick to differentiate the new building from 30 Caroline, aiming for a more modern and streamlined appearance. The design also incorporates more glass elements, which they believe will enhance the visibility of the historic restaurant.

As the commission continues to review the project, the outcome will significantly impact the community's architectural landscape and the preservation of its historical identity. The next steps will involve further discussions and potential revisions to address the concerns raised by residents and preservation advocates.