Middletown Council rejects Penrose LLC housing plan citing parking and density concerns

In a special meeting held on April 29, 2025, the Middletown Town Council engaged in a heated discussion regarding a proposed affordable housing project at 650 Greenan Avenue and 26 Hollifin Lane. The meeting highlighted the ongoing struggle between the need for increased housing and community concerns about density and infrastructure.

Council members expressed a mix of support and opposition to the project, with significant emphasis placed on the adequacy of parking and the overall fit of the proposed three-story buildings within the neighborhood. One council member articulated concerns about the project's parking plan, labeling it a "failed plan" and suggesting that the density of units was excessive for the area. The sentiment was echoed by others who felt that a two-story design would be more appropriate and better received by the community.

The discussion also touched on the broader implications of state mandates for affordable housing, with some council members arguing that towns should not be forced to adopt urban-like densities that do not align with their character. This tension reflects a larger statewide issue, as Rhode Island grapples with a housing crisis that has left many residents without adequate shelter.

Despite the concerns raised, the council ultimately moved forward with a resolution to authorize Penrose LLC to proceed with the revised plan. This decision, however, was met with dissent from some members who felt that the project did not adequately address the community's needs. The resolution allows for further review and potential adjustments before the plans are submitted for state financing in 2026.

The meeting concluded with a recognition of the ongoing challenges facing Middletown, including homelessness and the need for more affordable housing options. Council members acknowledged that while the current proposal may not be ideal, the urgency of the housing crisis necessitates continued efforts to find viable solutions. As the council prepares for future discussions, the community's input and the balance between development and local character will remain critical factors in shaping Middletown's housing landscape.