Liberty Police Chief demands action on Knights Inn safety crisis amid rising crime

The Sullivan County Public Safety and Law Enforcement Committee convened on May 1, 2025, to address pressing public safety concerns, particularly surrounding the Knights Inn Hotel in Liberty. Chief DeGotte of the Liberty Police Department presented alarming statistics indicating a significant rise in criminal incidents at the hotel, which has become a focal point for law enforcement activity.

In the first quarter of 2025, the police department responded to 64 unique criminal incidents at the Knights Inn, resulting in 165 hours of police time—equivalent to nearly seven full days of resources. Notably, 24 arrests were made during this period, with 82% of incidents involving individuals placed there by the Department of Social Services (DSS). Chief DeGotte emphasized that the current situation is untenable for both the residents of the hotel and the broader community, as the high volume of police activity has severely limited patrol services throughout Liberty.

The chief called for immediate action from the county legislature, urging the implementation of a professionally managed shelter with adequate security and services to transition individuals into long-term housing. He stressed that emergency housing should not serve as a permanent solution and highlighted the need for on-site security at the Knights Inn to mitigate risks.

Committee members engaged in discussions about the complexities of the situation, including the legal challenges of evicting individuals who have established residency after 28 days. They acknowledged the necessity of improving conditions at the hotel, including safety standards and security measures, to ensure the well-being of all residents.

The committee agreed on the importance of collaboration among various stakeholders, including the sheriff's office and health services, to address the underlying issues contributing to homelessness and crime in the area. They recognized that while immediate solutions are critical, a comprehensive approach is needed to prevent future incidents and support the community effectively.

In conclusion, the meeting underscored the urgent need for coordinated efforts to enhance public safety in Liberty and improve the living conditions for vulnerable populations. The committee plans to continue discussions and explore actionable steps to address these challenges in the coming weeks.