Wheeling Council tables ordinance banning feral cat feeding after public backlash

In the heart of Wheeling's city hall, a heated discussion unfolded as council members grappled with a proposed ordinance aimed at addressing the growing issue of feral and stray cats in the community. The meeting, held on April 1, 2025, saw passionate pleas from residents who voiced their concerns over the potential ban on feeding these animals, a move some argued could exacerbate the very problems it sought to solve.

Councilman Seidler, acknowledging the complexity of the issue, expressed regret over the initial proposal to make it illegal to feed feral cats. He emphasized the need for a more thoughtful approach, suggesting a trap-neuter-return (TNR) program as a viable alternative. "It was never my intent to harm any animals," he stated, indicating his willingness to table the ordinance for further discussion and community input.

As the council opened the floor to public comments, a diverse group of residents stepped forward, each sharing their perspectives. Michael Geertz, a local resident, argued against the ordinance, citing examples from places like Disneyland, where feral cats are fed to control rodent populations. He urged the council to focus on enforcing existing litter ordinances instead of penalizing those who care for stray animals.

Julie Croccio, another resident, echoed similar sentiments, highlighting the need for community-driven solutions rather than punitive measures. She pointed out that the proposed fines for feeding cats were disproportionately high compared to penalties for more serious offenses, raising questions about the council's priorities.

Others, like Angela Phillips, passionately defended the cats, warning that neglecting their needs could lead to increased health risks and a rise in abandoned animals. "This is what's going to happen," she cautioned, emphasizing the emotional toll of animal abandonment and the importance of compassion in addressing the issue.

The council's deliberations revealed a community divided yet united in their desire for a humane solution. As the meeting concluded, it became clear that the path forward would require collaboration and a commitment to finding effective, compassionate strategies for managing the feral cat population in Wheeling. With the ordinance tabled, residents left the meeting hopeful for a future where both animals and community concerns could be addressed in harmony.