Historic Review Board approves Hedges Eye Care renovation in historic district

During the City Commission Meeting on May 5, 2025, in Newberry, Florida, significant discussions centered around a proposed addition to the Hedges Eye Care building, located in the historic district. The meeting highlighted the importance of maintaining the architectural integrity of the area while accommodating new business developments.

John Paul Perez from the Community Development Department presented the request for a Certificate of Appropriateness, which is necessary for modifications to buildings within the historic district. The addition involves altering the exterior of the former Joel's Coffee location, which has been vacant since the previous business did not materialize. The new owner, Stephen Hedges, plans to relocate his ophthalmology practice to this site, marking a positive development for local healthcare access.

The proposed design respects the existing cracker and bungalow architectural style of the building, which is significant to the community's historical character. The addition will include a new gabled roof and a tower feature, reflecting an evolution of local architectural styles while ensuring minimal impact on the street-facing facade. The design aims to preserve a mural on the building, with future plans for its continuation or recreation pending further review.

The discussion underscored the balance between development and preservation, a critical theme for Newberry as it navigates growth while honoring its historical roots. The commission's approval of the Certificate of Appropriateness will allow the project to move forward, contributing to the local economy and enhancing community services.

As the meeting concluded, the commission emphasized the importance of ongoing dialogue about future developments in the historic district, ensuring that new projects align with the community's values and aesthetic. The next steps will involve further assessments of the mural and additional community input as the project progresses.