Developers discuss options for salvaging historic St. John's Lutheran Church

The Grove City Planning Commission meeting on May 6, 2025, focused on the future of the old St. John's Lutheran Church building, which has been under scrutiny due to its deteriorating condition and potential historical significance.

During the meeting, discussions revealed that the building, which has been vacant for some time, is facing demolition due to significant water damage and structural concerns. An architect involved in the evaluation noted that while the building's core structure remains sturdy, extensive flooding has caused considerable internal damage, including mold and compromised plumbing. As a result, the developers have indicated that the building is no longer salvageable.

Community members expressed their concerns about the potential loss of historical artifacts within the church. Linda Lewis, a local resident, highlighted previous findings of painted timbers and other significant elements that could be of historical value. She urged the developers to consider salvaging these components before proceeding with demolition. The developers acknowledged the community's concerns and indicated a willingness to explore options for salvaging any valuable materials, although they have not yet finalized their assessment.

Additionally, there was a suggestion to reach out to St. John's Church regarding a possible partnership to relocate some of the building's historical elements. The developers expressed openness to discussions with the church, recognizing the potential for collaboration in preserving the site's history.

The meeting concluded with a commitment from the developers to continue evaluating the building's condition and to keep the community informed about any developments. The timeline for demolition remains uncertain, as further assessments are needed to determine the fate of the structure and any salvageable materials.