Whitefish City Council approves solid waste fee increase amid mandatory service debate

The Whitefish City Council convened on May 5, 2025, to address pressing issues surrounding solid waste disposal services, culminating in the approval of a significant fee increase for residents. This decision comes as the city grapples with the financial implications of a ten-year contract with Republic Services, which mandates garbage collection for all residential properties.

During the meeting, council members discussed the potential consequences of altering the mandatory garbage service. Concerns were raised about the financial burden on residents if a significant portion of the population opted out of the service. The current contract stipulates that all properties in Whitefish are required to pay for garbage collection, regardless of usage. This means that even if residents choose to manage their waste independently, they are still liable for the mandatory fees.

The council debated the feasibility of spreading the proposed 18% rate increase over the ten-year contract period to ease the financial impact on residents. However, city staff clarified that failing to implement the increase would necessitate borrowing from the general fund, ultimately shifting the financial burden to taxpayers.

Council members acknowledged the need for a long-term discussion about the mandatory nature of garbage collection in Whitefish. While some expressed reservations about the current contract terms, they recognized that the immediate priority was to ensure the city could meet its financial obligations to Republic Services.

The resolution to revise solid waste disposal fees passed with a vote of 5 to 1, with Councilor Caltabiano opposing the motion. The council's decision reflects a commitment to maintaining essential services while navigating the complexities of municipal finance.

As the city moves forward, residents can expect further discussions on the future of mandatory garbage collection, which may lead to changes in how waste management is handled in Whitefish. The council's actions underscore the ongoing challenge of balancing community needs with fiscal responsibility.