Council discusses urgent condemnation of Manchester and Sunshine Buildings due to safety hazards

The City of Middletown Council convened on May 6, 2025, to address pressing safety concerns regarding the Manchester and Sunshine buildings, both of which have been the subject of ongoing discussions due to their deteriorating conditions.

The meeting began with a report from Fire Marshal Bauffman, who detailed a recent fire incident at the Manchester building. He described how a warming fire, likely contained in a metal container, spread beyond its confines, creating significant hazards. The fire vented through a fourth-floor window, leaving visible soot stains on the building's exterior. Bauffman emphasized that the building poses serious risks, not only to potential trespassers but also to first responders who may need to enter the structure in an emergency.

Councilman Horn raised concerns about the respiratory and fall hazards present in the building, urging that no first responders should be sent inside unless absolutely necessary. He highlighted the dangers posed by the building's structural integrity and the presence of void spaces that could lead to accidents. Horn called for the condemnation of both the Manchester and Sunshine buildings to prevent injuries and further liability for the city.

The discussion shifted towards the potential demolition of the buildings. Council members expressed a sense of urgency, with some advocating for immediate action rather than delaying until the scheduled work session in August. Councilman Horn proposed gathering cost estimates for the demolition of both buildings, emphasizing the need for a decisive plan moving forward.

Council members acknowledged the community's emotional ties to the buildings but stressed the importance of safety over sentimentality. They discussed the financial implications of restoration versus demolition, with estimates for restoring the Manchester building alone reaching nearly $18 million. The consensus leaned towards prioritizing public safety and exploring demolition options.

As the meeting concluded, it was agreed that staff would gather necessary information regarding costs and timelines for potential demolition. A follow-up work session is planned for August, where council members aim to make a definitive decision regarding the future of the Manchester and Sunshine buildings. The urgency of the situation was clear, with council members committed to ensuring the safety of the community and first responders alike.