Snoqualmie Landmarks Commission discusses historic color palette and guidelines for properties

The Snoqualmie Planning Commission convened on May 5, 2025, to discuss proposed amendments to the historic preservation code, particularly focusing on color palettes for buildings within the Landmark District. The meeting began with staff recommendations regarding the necessity of a preapproved color palette for individual landmarks and contributing buildings. Staff suggested that while a color palette might not be required for these structures, it could still be mandated for non-contributing buildings within the Landmark District and those in overlay zones.

The discussion highlighted three potential options for the color palette: maintaining the current palette without changes, allowing a mix of the existing 16 colors, or permitting a combination of the current palette with an additional 24 Sherwin Williams colors, with a recommendation against using black as a primary color. The staff emphasized the importance of maintaining the integrity of the Landmark District while also considering aesthetic standards for the downtown area.

Commissioners expressed varied opinions on the proposed options. Some voiced concerns about the relevance of color choices in preserving historical context, while others argued for more flexibility to accommodate business needs. Vice Chair Kocoup noted the importance of balancing historical preservation with aesthetic considerations, while Commissioner Hurley advocated for expanding the color palette to include more options, including pastels.

The conversation also touched on the administrative review process for color approvals, with some commissioners questioning the necessity of strict color prescriptions. Council Member Johnson raised concerns about the potential for arbitrary decisions without clear guidelines, suggesting that a lack of bounds could lead to undesirable outcomes in color choices.

Ultimately, the commission leaned towards supporting a more flexible approach, with several members favoring the third option of mixing and matching colors. The discussion concluded with a consensus on the need for further exploration of the guidelines and the potential for administrative discretion in color approvals.

The meeting underscored the ongoing dialogue between preserving Snoqualmie's historical character and accommodating the evolving needs of its business community, with plans for further review and potential adjustments to the proposed color guidelines in future sessions.