Bexley design board reviews renovations for historic home on U Claire Street

In a recent meeting of the City of Bexley Architectural Review Board, a proposed renovation of a historic home sparked significant discussion among board members and community supporters. The homeowner, who aims to enhance the back of the house while preserving its original architectural elements, presented plans that included replicating the front columns in the rear design. However, the board expressed concerns over the level of detail and professionalism in the submitted drawings.

The homeowner emphasized their intention to maintain the house's character by using original bricks from the existing stoop in the new design. Support from neighbors highlighted the positive transformation of the property since it was sold by Capital University, with one resident praising the homeowner's efforts to restore the home's beauty.

Despite the enthusiasm, board members raised critical questions about the design's structural integrity and aesthetic alignment with the historic nature of the house. Concerns included the need for more detailed, professionally drawn plans to ensure accurate measurements and material choices. One board member noted, "We don’t approve intent; we approve design," stressing the importance of clarity in the proposed renovations.

The discussion also touched on the materials proposed for the roof of the extension, with board members suggesting alternatives to the clear plastic initially considered. They urged the homeowner to refine the design to better reflect the home's historical significance.

As the meeting concluded, the board indicated that further revisions would be necessary before any approval could be granted. The homeowner was encouraged to seek professional assistance to enhance the design's quality and ensure it meets the standards expected for such an important property in Bexley. The next steps will involve revisiting the plans with a focus on detailed architectural drawings and appropriate material selections, aiming to honor the home's legacy while accommodating modern family needs.