Neighbors oppose Anthony Brown's request for corner lot fence variance in St. John

The Board of Zoning Appeals meeting held on May 7, 2025, in St. John, Indiana, focused on a contentious request for a variance to construct a six-foot privacy fence at the corner of 96 Place and Triana Lane. This proposal has sparked significant concern among local residents, primarily regarding safety and aesthetics.

During the meeting, several neighbors voiced their opposition to the fence, citing safety issues related to visibility at the intersection. One resident, who lives adjacent to the proposed site, expressed that the fence would obstruct sightlines for drivers and pedestrians, particularly children, as they navigate the curve where Triana Lane meets 96 Place. The absence of a stop sign at this corner exacerbates the risk, as vehicles often travel at high speeds, making it difficult for drivers to see oncoming traffic or pedestrians.

Another resident echoed these sentiments, emphasizing that the fence would not only impair visibility but also detract from the neighborhood's overall appearance. Concerns were raised about the fence's potential to create a "blind corner," which could lead to accidents involving pedestrians, especially young children who frequently play in the area.

The board received multiple emails from residents unable to attend the meeting, all expressing similar concerns. Many emphasized that while privacy is important, it should not come at the expense of safety and community aesthetics. The consensus among the community members was clear: the proposed fence could pose a significant hazard and disrupt the visual harmony of the neighborhood.

As the meeting concluded, the board was left to weigh the residents' concerns against the homeowner's desire for privacy. The discussions highlighted the ongoing tension between individual property rights and community safety, a common theme in zoning debates. The board's decision on the variance request will be crucial, as it will set a precedent for future developments in the area and reflect the town's commitment to balancing personal freedoms with public safety.