Matthew Salisbury's pardon request denied after victim's powerful testimony

In a somber yet pivotal session held on May 7, 2025, the Connecticut Board of Pardons and Paroles convened to deliberate on the case of Matthew Salisbury, who sought an absolute pardon following a serious DUI incident that occurred over seven years ago. The atmosphere was charged with emotion as Salisbury, now a diesel mechanic and union member, expressed his commitment to personal growth and responsibility since the incident.

Salisbury's past actions had devastating consequences for the victim, Richard Crumble, who was struck while cycling home from work. Crumble's harrowing account, read by a representative from the Office of Victim Services, detailed the severe injuries he sustained, including a fractured spine and multiple surgeries. He described the lasting impact of the collision, which not only altered his physical health but also left him grappling with PTSD. Despite the trauma, Crumble extended forgiveness to Salisbury, urging him to embrace responsibility moving forward.

During the hearing, board members scrutinized Salisbury's progress since his conviction. While he highlighted his achievements—such as obtaining a Commercial Driver's License (CDL) and completing community service—questions arose regarding his ongoing relationship with alcohol. Salisbury admitted to drinking socially, which raised concerns among board members about his readiness for a pardon.

The board's deliberation reflected a deep consideration of the victim's suffering and the seriousness of Salisbury's past actions. Ultimately, the board voted unanimously to deny the pardon, citing the need for Salisbury to continue demonstrating his commitment to positive change and community service before reapplying in the future.

As the session concluded, the board encouraged Salisbury to remain on his path of improvement, leaving the door open for future opportunities. The poignant exchange underscored the complexities of forgiveness, accountability, and the long road to redemption for those seeking a second chance.