Nantucket zoning board discusses town tree protections amid construction concerns

The Nantucket Zoning Board of Appeals convened on May 8, 2025, to discuss various issues related to a proposed construction project that raised concerns about the potential impact on a nearby town tree. The meeting focused on the implications of the project, particularly regarding the protection of the tree and the management of construction debris.

The discussion began with board members addressing the legal framework surrounding town trees. It was noted that while there are penalties for damaging a town tree, the fines are minimal and lack substantial enforcement power. This led to a conversation about the need for clearer guidelines on what citizens can do regarding town trees, as well as the responsibilities of the construction team.

A key point raised was the potential for damage to the tree during construction activities. Board members expressed concerns about the removal of stairs and the possibility of soil compaction affecting the tree's root system. Suggestions were made to condition the project approval on the establishment of a protective fence around the tree's root area to prevent disturbance.

The board also discussed the logistics of construction debris removal, emphasizing the need for a plan that minimizes disruption to the surrounding area. It was highlighted that the project site is located on a busy street, which could complicate debris transport and increase traffic congestion.

As the meeting progressed, members debated the extent of their authority in enforcing tree protection measures. While they acknowledged the importance of safeguarding the tree, they recognized that the enforcement of tree protection laws falls outside their jurisdiction. Instead, they suggested that the applicant voluntarily agree to consult with the town arborist and implement best practices for tree protection during construction.

Ultimately, the applicant's representative indicated a willingness to cooperate, proposing to install a silt fence along the property line and commit to minimizing any potential harm to the tree. The board members expressed their inclination to approve the project, contingent upon these protective measures being formally included in the decision.

In conclusion, the meeting underscored the complexities of balancing development with environmental stewardship. The board's discussions highlighted the need for clear communication between the construction team, the town arborist, and the zoning board to ensure that the interests of the community and the preservation of town trees are adequately addressed. The next steps will involve formalizing the conditions of approval and ensuring that all parties are aligned on the project's execution.