Providence City Council considers Excel Academy lease for Carnegie Library Building

In the heart of Providence, a passionate plea echoed through the city council chambers on May 12, 2025, as community members gathered to advocate for a transformative educational opportunity. The focus of the evening was the proposed lease of the Carl G. Lawyer Building to Excel Academy, a charter school poised to expand its reach and serve more families in the area.

One by one, speakers shared their personal stories, weaving a narrative of hope and determination. A resident from the South Side spoke of the challenges faced by black and brown families in accessing quality education, housing, and healthcare. With a heartfelt commitment to community collaboration, she highlighted the importance of high-quality education as a fundamental right, urging council members to support the lease. “This isn’t just a building. It’s about the future we’re building for our children,” she emphasized, reflecting the sentiments of many who believe that education is a pathway to success.

Parents echoed these sentiments, sharing their experiences with Excel Academy. One mother recounted her son’s struggles in traditional schooling, only to flourish after receiving personalized support at Excel. “As families, we feel supported,” she said, underscoring the school’s role in fostering a nurturing environment for students. Another speaker, a board member of Excel Academy, acknowledged the valid concerns surrounding charter schools but urged for constructive dialogue rather than misinformation. “These are not abstract policy debates. They affect real families in our community,” he stated, advocating for a collaborative approach to education that benefits all students, regardless of their background.

The discussions were not without their challenges, as some council members raised concerns about the implications of charter schools on the public education system. However, the overwhelming message from the community was clear: families are not seeking special treatment; they are asking for equitable access to quality education. “We all want the same thing for our kids—to be safe, supported, and successful,” one parent remarked, calling for unity rather than division among educational institutions.

As the meeting drew to a close, the urgency of the moment was palpable. The vacant Carl G. Lawyer Building stands as a symbol of potential, waiting to be transformed into a vibrant educational hub. The community’s voices resonated with a shared vision for a brighter future, one where every child in Providence has the opportunity to thrive. The council’s decision on the lease will not only impact the immediate educational landscape but will also shape the aspirations of countless families seeking a fair chance at success.