Portland council faces backlash over Housing First proposal from local residents

A heated debate erupted at the City of Portland's Special Housing & Economic Development Committee meeting on May 6, 2025, as community members voiced strong opposition to a proposal allocating 30% of new housing units to a "housing first" model. Critics argue that this approach, which includes wraparound services similar to those found in homeless shelters, misrepresents itself as affordable housing and could exacerbate local issues.

One vocal opponent claimed the proposal would turn Portland into a "national destination for dependency," highlighting that over half of the city's homeless population comes from out of state. They expressed concern that the initiative would lead to increased crime and instability in neighborhoods, particularly those near schools and economic development projects. "You’re choosing to prioritize people with no ties to this community," they stated, warning that the plan would punish local residents and businesses.

In contrast, representatives from Community Housing and Maine (CHAM) defended the proposal, emphasizing their commitment to creating quality affordable housing that integrates supportive services. They highlighted successful past projects and their collaborative approach with local neighborhoods, asserting that their developments have transformed lives and fostered community pride.

The meeting underscored a significant divide in perspectives on how to address homelessness and housing in Portland. While some residents fear the implications of the housing first model, advocates argue it is a necessary step toward solving the city's ongoing homelessness crisis. As discussions continue, the committee faces the challenge of balancing community concerns with the urgent need for effective housing solutions.