New Freedom Borough considers controversial renter's ordinance amid public outcry

The New Freedom Borough Council meeting on May 12, 2025, highlighted significant community concerns regarding a proposed rental ordinance aimed at improving housing conditions. The discussions revealed a divide between landlords and tenants, with passionate public comments reflecting the complexities of housing regulations in the borough.

During the public comment segment, Sherry Miller, a local landlord, expressed her support for improving housing conditions but cautioned against overly punitive regulations that could harm responsible landlords. She emphasized the need for accountability rather than blanket policies that could burden those who already maintain safe and clean properties. Miller advocated for a more nuanced approach, suggesting mandatory inspections only in response to valid complaints and tiered accountability for landlords based on their compliance history.

Conversely, tenant voices raised concerns about the proposed ordinance's implications for privacy and rights. Christie Smith, a renter, questioned the reasonableness of allowing codes enforcement officers to enter homes at any time, arguing that such measures could infringe on tenants' privacy rights. She highlighted existing Pennsylvania laws that already protect renters, suggesting that the borough's involvement might be unnecessary and intrusive.

Devin Taylor, another resident and veteran, voiced strong opposition to the ordinance, framing it as an overreach that could deter property owners and small businesses from operating in New Freedom. He argued that excessive regulations could undermine the community's appeal and affordability, ultimately harming both renters and landlords.

The meeting underscored the delicate balance between ensuring safe housing and respecting the rights of both tenants and landlords. As the council considers the proposed ordinance, the discussions reflect broader themes of governance, community responsibility, and the need for policies that address the concerns of all stakeholders involved. The outcome of this ordinance could significantly impact the housing landscape in New Freedom, making it essential for the council to navigate these discussions thoughtfully.