Grass Valley approves demolition of historic barn at 603 West Main Street for ADU

In a recent meeting held at Grass Valley City Hall, the Historical Commission discussed the proposed demolition of a historic barn located at 603 West Main Street. Built in 1885, this barn has been classified as a priority 2 structure, indicating its significance to the area's historical character. However, the barn has undergone numerous alterations over the years, leading to concerns about its integrity and historical value.

The barn, described as a two-story, salt box style carriage barn, features distinctive architectural elements such as a Cape Cod style shed roof and wide clapboard siding. Despite its historical roots, an updated evaluation by historian Dana Supernovitz concluded that the barn no longer meets the criteria for historical significance due to extensive modifications, including the replacement of original materials and structural changes.

During the meeting, the applicant proposed to demolish the existing barn and replace it with a new accessory dwelling unit (ADU) that would mimic the barn's original aesthetic. The new structure would be slightly relocated to avoid encroaching on the city’s right of way. The commission expressed support for the demolition, contingent upon adherence to design standards that would ensure the new building maintains a similar appearance to the original.

Commission members shared personal anecdotes about the barn's history, highlighting its role in the community as a place where horses were once kept. Concerns were raised about the potential for the site to remain vacant after demolition, emphasizing the importance of ensuring that a new structure is built promptly.

The architect representing the owners, Arthur and Helene Fellows, confirmed their intention to create a new building that respects the historical context of the area while providing modern living space. The commission acknowledged the owners' commitment to preserving the salt box style, which has been a defining feature of the neighborhood for generations.

As the meeting concluded, the commission expressed appreciation for the owners' plans and the thoughtful approach to balancing historical preservation with contemporary needs. The future of the barn site remains a topic of interest, as the community looks forward to seeing how the new structure will contribute to the historical landscape of Grass Valley.