Historic District Commission splits approval for 41 School Street roof and window restoration

The Newport Historic District Commission convened on May 13, 2025, to discuss several applications concerning restoration and renovation projects within the historic district. The meeting focused on two primary applications, with discussions centering on the restoration of windows and roofs, as well as the replacement of materials in compliance with preservation standards.

The first application addressed was for 41 School Street, where the applicant sought approval for roof and window restoration. The commission noted the need for additional documentation regarding the removal and replacement of a door, as well as the front porch's condition, which had undergone previous repairs. After deliberation, the commission agreed to split the application, allowing for the immediate approval of the roof and window restoration while deferring other aspects for further review. The commission emphasized that the windows would be restored rather than replaced, adhering to the Newport standards for preservation.

Following the approval of the first part of the application, the commission moved to the next item on the agenda, which involved an abbreviated summary for 23 Sherman Street. The applicant proposed replacing wooden gutters with aluminum, raising concerns about maintaining the character-defining features of the property. The commission suggested using fiberglass gutters to preserve the original profile, which the applicant agreed to. The application was subsequently approved with the condition that the materials be updated to fiberglass.

The meeting concluded with a discussion on the application for 60 Third Street, which included extensive renovations such as replacing asbestos siding with cedar shingles and constructing a second story. The applicant presented updated plans for the project, which were accepted by the commission.

Overall, the meeting highlighted the commission's commitment to preserving the historical integrity of Newport's architecture while balancing the needs of property owners for renovations and restorations. The next meeting is scheduled for June 10, 2025, where further discussions on deferred applications will take place.