Utica City Council approves temporary fireworks sales despite sign ordinance concerns

A heated debate over signage regulations and temporary fireworks sales unfolded at the Utica City Council meeting on May 13, 2025, as council members grappled with balancing business interests and community safety.

The discussion ignited when a local business owner expressed frustration over the city's sign variance process. He argued that while his request for a larger sign was denied, competitors like Jimmy John's were allowed to display significantly larger signs on city property. "I pay over a hundred thousand dollars in property taxes, yet I can't get a variance to increase business in an area where business has failed three times," he lamented. This sentiment resonated with some council members, who questioned the fairness of the current regulations.

The council ultimately voted to approve the business owner's request for a temporary fireworks sales tent, but only under strict conditions, including adherence to the city’s sign ordinance, which limits temporary signage to 12 square feet. The owner acknowledged the need for visibility but was urged to comply with the regulations to avoid future complications.

In a related discussion, another fireworks vendor sought approval for a similar setup at a different location. The council reiterated the importance of following the sign ordinance, emphasizing that any signage exceeding the limit would not be tolerated. "If it's not within 12 square feet, we're going to have problems," warned Mayor Calandrino.

The council's decision reflects ongoing tensions between fostering local business growth and ensuring community safety and aesthetics. As the city prepares for the upcoming fireworks season, officials are considering the potential need for a more comprehensive ordinance governing temporary sales, aiming to strike a balance that benefits both businesses and residents.