Harrisonburg Commission debates alley closure near historic cemetery site

Harrisonburg's Planning Commission is grappling with a complex decision regarding the potential closure of an alley adjacent to a historic cemetery, a move that could significantly impact local residents and the preservation of community history. During the meeting on May 14, 2025, commissioners discussed the implications of closing the alley, which some argue is necessary to protect the sanctity of the burial site, while others emphasize the need for pedestrian access and connectivity in the neighborhood.

The discussion highlighted concerns about pedestrian safety, particularly in areas lacking sidewalks. One commissioner expressed frustration over the challenges faced by residents trying to navigate the neighborhood without safe routes. The conversation also touched on the historical significance of the cemetery, which is recognized as a sacred space for the local Black community. Several commissioners underscored the importance of preserving this site, noting that it has not received adequate attention in the past.

As the commission deliberated, the potential for a compromise emerged. One suggestion included maintaining a five-foot pedestrian easement to allow foot traffic while closing the alley to vehicular access. This proposal aims to balance the need for safe passage with the respect owed to the gravesites, which may not be clearly marked.

The meeting also revealed differing opinions on the necessity of the alley for local residents. While some commissioners noted that there were indications of vehicle use, others questioned the extent of that need, given the physical barriers presented by trees and the proximity of graves.

Ultimately, the commission faces a challenging decision that weighs community access against the preservation of a significant historical site. As discussions continue, the outcome will likely shape the neighborhood's landscape and its residents' daily lives, emphasizing the need for thoughtful consideration of both history and modern community needs.