Historic District Board approves Hardy siding replacement and shutter recommendations

The Winchester Board of Architectural Review convened on May 15, 2025, at 4:00 PM to discuss several key topics related to architectural modifications within the city. The meeting primarily focused on the proposed replacement of aluminum siding with Hardiplank siding on a residential property, alongside discussions on preservation initiatives.

The first significant agenda item involved a detailed examination of the proposed siding replacement. A representative for the homeowner presented the plan to replace the existing aluminum siding with smooth Hardiplank, emphasizing that this material would enhance the home's aesthetic appeal while maintaining historical integrity. The board discussed the specifics of the trim work, including the use of Hardy trim boards and the color scheme, which is expected to match existing features like the freeze board.

Concerns were raised regarding the corners of the siding, with discussions on whether to use vertical trim boards or corner straps. The consensus leaned towards using a smooth finish for the Hardiplank, as it would align more closely with the historical character of the home compared to the current aluminum siding. The board noted that the property is located just outside the National Historic District, which influenced their decision-making process.

A motion was made to approve the replacement of the aluminum siding with smooth Hardiplank, with the stipulation that if the existing shutters were damaged during the process, they must be replaced with wooden shutters rather than vinyl. The board also encouraged the homeowner to investigate the possibility of uncovering any original stucco beneath the aluminum siding, suggesting that this could further enhance the home's historical value.

Following the siding discussion, the board shifted focus to upcoming preservation initiatives. Plans were outlined for Preservation Month, including a feature in the next edition of WindConnect and the distribution of pamphlets to property owners within the historic district. The pamphlets aim to raise awareness about preservation efforts and engage the community in maintaining the historical character of Winchester.

The meeting concluded with a commitment to continue supporting preservation efforts and ensuring that any modifications to historic properties align with the city's architectural guidelines. The board's proactive approach reflects a dedication to balancing modern needs with the preservation of Winchester's historical heritage.