Smithfield Town Council appoints Chief Robert Seltzer as permanent town manager

The Smithfield Town Council made a significant decision during its meeting on May 13, 2025, by appointing Chief Robert Seltzer as the permanent town manager. This appointment comes after a lengthy selection process that began in October 2024, following the departure of former town manager Randy Rossi. Seltzer will receive a salary of $156,000 along with his existing benefits package.

Councilwoman Tholvis, who proposed the appointment, highlighted the extensive efforts taken by the town manager search committee, which included public members with relevant experience. The committee conducted thorough interviews and evaluations of candidates, ultimately recommending Seltzer based on his qualifications and community support. Tholvis praised Seltzer's leadership skills and his commitment to the town, noting his 36 years of public service, including 13 years as the Smithfield Fire Chief.

However, the appointment was not without controversy. Some council members expressed dissatisfaction with the selection process, arguing that it lacked transparency and inclusivity. Councilman Iannotti criticized the decision to forego an external recruitment firm, which he believed limited the pool of qualified candidates. He voiced concerns about the abrupt conclusion of the interview process and the lack of a formal discussion among council members regarding the candidates.

Despite the dissent, the council proceeded with a roll call vote, resulting in a majority in favor of Seltzer's appointment. In his acceptance speech, Seltzer expressed gratitude for the community's support and emphasized his commitment to serving the town effectively.

In addition to the town manager appointment, the council also addressed various administrative matters, including the reappointment of members to several town boards and commissions. The next council meeting is scheduled for May 20, 2025, where further discussions and decisions are expected.