Local Council approves tree planting despite resident concerns over sidewalks and allergies

Concerns over tree planting in Sheboygan took center stage at the recent Public Works Committee meeting, as residents voiced strong objections based on personal experiences and neighborhood conditions.

One resident, citing multiple back surgeries and mobility issues, expressed frustration over the potential obstruction a new tree could create near his driveway. He highlighted the existing problems with cracked curbs and uneven sidewalks, suggesting that the city should prioritize repairing these issues rather than planting new trees. “I just feel I'm against that,” he stated, emphasizing the need for better infrastructure over additional greenery.

Another resident raised concerns about allergies, stating that their wife’s sensitivity to pollen would be exacerbated by planting a new tree. They questioned whether the city would take responsibility for maintaining the area around the tree, given their long history of lawn care. The city’s tree selection, specifically the scarlet fire dogwood, was defended by officials, who noted that it was chosen for its suitability and distance from utilities.

The discussion also touched on the condition of sidewalks in older neighborhoods, with one resident advocating for repairs over new tree plantings. They described the hazardous state of the sidewalks, which have been damaged by tree roots, making it difficult for elderly residents and children to navigate safely. “I wish they'd spend the money fixing and repairing before they plant more trees,” they urged, suggesting that the city should focus on infrastructure improvements.

In a split decision, the committee approved the appeal for one tree planting, while another proposal faced opposition, reflecting the community's divided stance on the balance between urban forestry and essential infrastructure maintenance. As the city continues to promote its status as a "Tree City," residents are calling for a more thoughtful approach that considers the existing challenges in their neighborhoods.