Reformed Episcopal Church seeks approval for shingle roof on historic property

During a recent government meeting in Summerville, the Reformed Episcopal Church presented a proposal to replace the metal roof of its historic building at 705 South Main Street. Built in 1901 and formerly known as Pinewood School, the church is facing significant financial challenges in maintaining the property. The proposed replacement of the existing metal roof, which is deemed irreparable, would cost $170,000. In contrast, the church is seeking approval to install a shingle roof for $50,000, a more affordable option.

The discussion highlighted the building's historical significance and its prominent location on Main Street, prompting concerns from some board members about the aesthetic implications of switching to shingles. One member expressed strong opposition, stating that replacing the metal roof with shingles would detract from the building's architectural merit and historical value. The debate centered around the need to balance financial constraints with the preservation of the town's heritage.

Ultimately, the board voted to approve the use of shingles on a smaller outbuilding on the property, while deferring the decision on the main building's roof until further discussions could take place regarding the color and material. The motion passed with a vote of 5 to 2, reflecting a compromise between the church's financial needs and the community's desire to maintain the historical integrity of the site.

In addition to the roof discussions, the meeting also addressed plans for a new garage on Central Avenue. Concerns were raised about the garage's design, which some members felt lacked architectural detail and did not complement the adjacent historic home. Suggestions were made to enhance the garage's appearance to better align with the character of the neighborhood.

As the meeting concluded, the board emphasized the importance of preserving the town's historical landmarks while also considering the practical needs of property owners. The outcomes of these discussions will play a crucial role in shaping the future of Summerville's architectural landscape.