Developers seek Cedar Fence to Address Privacy Issues in Oakley Subdivision

The Oakley City Planning Commission held a meeting on December 5, 2024, to discuss significant changes proposed for a subdivision project, particularly focusing on the installation of a cedar privacy fence along State Road 32. The discussion highlighted concerns from both developers and commission members regarding the impact of these changes on the community and existing residents.

The primary issue at hand was the request for a six-foot cedar fence to provide privacy for new homeowners from neighboring properties and noise from the highway. Developers argued that potential buyers were hesitant to purchase lots without adequate privacy measures, which they deemed essential for the project's viability. They emphasized that the proposed fence would not only enhance the aesthetic appeal of the subdivision but also offer necessary protection from noise and visual disturbances.

However, several commission members expressed reservations about the fence's necessity and its implications for the community's character. Concerns were raised about setting a precedent for future developments and the potential for a "hodgepodge" of varying fence styles if individual homeowners chose to install their own fences. Some members argued that the original design of the subdivision, which did not include privacy fences, should be maintained to preserve the open feel of Oakley.

The commission debated whether to approve the fence request or to table the discussion for further consideration. Some members suggested that the developers should return with a revised plan that aligns more closely with the community's vision. The meeting underscored the tension between the need for privacy in new developments and the desire to maintain the aesthetic and open character of the area.

As the commission continues to deliberate on this matter, the outcome will likely influence future development standards and community planning in Oakley. The next steps will involve further discussions and potential revisions to the proposed plans to ensure they meet both developer needs and community expectations.