Historic House Renovation Proposes Taller Glass Railing and New Gate Design

The Manhattan Community Board 2 Landmarks Committee convened on May 15, 2025, to discuss various proposals concerning local architectural modifications and historical preservation. The meeting focused on the proposed changes to a residential property at 78 Washington Place, which included the installation of a new glass railing and modifications to the existing fence and gate.

The committee began with a presentation showcasing a photo montage of the proposed glass railing, highlighting its minimal visibility from Washington Square Park. The new design is intended to replace an existing wooden fence, which will be 8 inches taller than its predecessor. The rationale for this increase in height was discussed, with committee members noting both practical considerations and the need for aesthetic continuity with neighboring properties.

A significant point of discussion centered on the design of the new gate, which is described as a simplified version of the previous design that was deemed historically inaccurate. The new gate will feature spikes and a V-shaped base, aligning more closely with the architectural style of the 1920s rather than the earlier Greek Revival style that had been previously replicated.

Committee members raised questions about the appropriateness of the proposed gas lanterns for the entrance, noting that such fixtures are uncommon in the neighborhood. The historical context of the house, originally built in 1838 and remodeled in 1920, was also examined, with members acknowledging the challenges of maintaining historical integrity while accommodating modern needs.

The meeting concluded with a discussion on the balance between individuality in design and adherence to historical references, emphasizing the importance of thoughtful modifications that respect the character of the neighborhood. The committee plans to continue deliberations on these proposals in future sessions, with public input being welcomed for further consideration.