City Council approves tree planting amid sidewalk concerns from elderly residents

The Public Works Committee of Sheboygan convened on May 20, 2025, to address several community concerns regarding tree planting and sidewalk conditions in the city. The meeting featured discussions from residents about the impact of trees on sidewalks and the maintenance of public spaces.

The first resident expressed concerns about a previously removed tree, suggesting that its roots had caused cracks in the curb. He noted that while he pays for lawn care, he does not see the need for additional trees, citing numerous vacant spots in the city that could accommodate new plantings. He criticized the city’s approach to sidewalk maintenance, arguing that the decision to cut around tree roots rather than remove them entirely had resulted in wasted resources on concrete repairs.

Another resident, Mr. Myron, voiced his opposition to planting a new tree due to his wife's pollen allergies, stating that he has maintained his lawn for 20 years and believes he should have control over the landscaping in his yard. He raised concerns about the potential for the city to plant a tree in a space he considers his property.

Tim, a city representative, responded to these concerns by explaining that the proposed tree, a scarlet fire dogwood, was selected based on its suitability for the designated space, which was deemed appropriate given the distance from utilities. He acknowledged the allergy concerns and mentioned that alternative tree species could be considered.

The committee then voted on the appeal to plant the tree, which passed with a 3-2 vote despite the objections raised.

Later in the meeting, Carrie Strasburg and Diane Dean presented issues regarding the sidewalks in their neighborhood, which they described as severely damaged due to aging trees. They highlighted the difficulties faced by elderly residents, including their inability to navigate the uneven sidewalks. Strasburg emphasized the need for repairs rather than new tree plantings, arguing that the current conditions discourage walking and pose safety risks.

The committee's discussions underscored the ongoing tension between urban forestry initiatives and the practical concerns of residents regarding property maintenance and public safety. The meeting concluded with a commitment to further evaluate the sidewalk conditions and consider the residents' appeals for repairs.