HDC faces accountability issues over historic district approvals in local planning meeting

A critical discussion unfolded during the Kingston Select Board meeting on May 19, 2025, focusing on the enforcement challenges faced by the Historic District Commission (HDC) regarding building permits and aesthetic compliance. The conversation highlighted a significant gap in the enforcement capabilities of the HDC, which is primarily an aesthetic committee rather than a safety authority.

Members expressed concern that the HDC lacks the power to enforce compliance with its own approvals, particularly when it comes to ensuring that developers adhere to the conditions set forth in their certificates of approval. This issue was underscored by recent instances where developers proceeded with projects without necessary aesthetic considerations, such as landscaping around electric panels, leading to frustration among board members.

One board member pointed out that while the HDC can approve designs, it cannot enforce them if they do not constitute a health or safety violation. This limitation has resulted in situations where homeowners are not held accountable for deviations from HDC guidelines, as there is no clear enforcement mechanism in place. The discussion suggested that the board may need to explore options like performance bonds to incentivize compliance and protect the town's aesthetic standards.

The meeting concluded with a consensus on the need for the HDC to be more diligent in detailing conditions in their approvals to prevent future issues. Board members acknowledged that clearer guidelines and a more robust enforcement strategy could help maintain the historical integrity of Kingston while also providing developers with a clearer understanding of their obligations. Further discussions are anticipated to refine the application process and address these enforcement challenges effectively.