Architects propose Dunkin' Donuts renovation for historic Leesburg bank building

The Leesburg Board of Architectural Review convened on May 21, 2025, to discuss a proposal for the transformation of a historic bank building into a Dunkin' Donuts. The meeting focused on various architectural modifications aimed at enhancing the building's functionality while maintaining its aesthetic integrity.

The proposal includes several key alterations: infilling the second-story center window on the northeast elevation with double doors to create a pedestrian entry, replacing the brick infill on the northwest elevation with a window that matches existing fenestration, and installing an orange metal awning above the proposed double doors. Additionally, the plan involves replacing a single entry door on the northwest elevation and adding decorative metal bands backlit with LED strip lighting between the first and second story windows on the side elevations. A canopy over the drive-thru menu board is also part of the design.

Staff members expressed that the proposed changes are generally compatible with the surrounding architecture, noting that the design blends well without mimicking its neighbors. However, concerns were raised regarding the orange metal bands, which some members felt could draw excessive attention to the small space between the windows. Suggestions were made to consider individual awnings instead, although the applicant explained that corporate guidelines discourage fabric awnings due to maintenance issues.

The discussion also touched on the existing window design, which features a faux colonial style with multiple mutton patterns. Some board members argued that maintaining this design would be more appropriate for the building's historical context, while others suggested simplifying the windows to a single-pane appearance.

The meeting concluded with the applicants, Jason Scott and Ian and Christian Cabral, present to answer questions. They clarified that the refuse area would consist of a freestanding dumpster enclosure made of brick to match the building, ensuring consistency in materials.

Overall, the board's deliberations highlighted the balance between modern commercial needs and the preservation of historical architectural elements. The next steps will involve further discussions and potential motions for approval or deferral of the proposal.