Fort Collins residents debate short term rental regulations and land use changes

The Fort Collins City Planning and Zoning Commission meeting on May 15, 2025, focused on the contentious issue of short-term rentals (STRs) in the city, particularly in the Old Town North area. Residents and property owners expressed concerns about the potential impact of proposed changes to land use regulations that could limit STRs.

Several speakers highlighted the growing trend of properties being converted into STRs, raising fears that this shift could lead to a lack of permanent residents in the neighborhood. One resident noted that if current trends continue without intervention, Old Town North could become entirely dominated by STRs, which would alter the community's character and accessibility for long-term residents.

Greg Robertson, a local homeowner, shared his personal experience of living among multiple STRs, emphasizing the need for the city to align its policies across all neighborhoods. He argued that the exemption for Old Town North should be reconsidered, suggesting that allowing STRs in other parts of the neighborhood could help address housing shortages.

Josh Tinker, another property owner, raised concerns about the economic implications of reducing STRs. He argued that limiting these rentals could drive visitors to seek accommodations outside the city, resulting in lost revenue for local businesses. Tinker called for a more collaborative approach to address the issues surrounding STRs, advocating for discussions that include all stakeholders.

The meeting underscored the complexities of balancing community needs with economic interests, as residents voiced their desire for a solution that preserves the integrity of their neighborhoods while also considering the financial benefits of STRs. The commission is expected to continue discussions on this topic, weighing the concerns of residents against the potential economic impacts of any regulatory changes.