Tiburon neighbors challenge Landmark Society on wedding noise permit regulations

Residents of Tiburon are voicing strong concerns regarding the operations of the Belvedere Tiburon Landmarks Society at the Art and Garden Center, particularly about the frequency and noise levels of amplified events. During the Tiburon Town Council meeting on May 21, 2025, community members presented their appeal against a conditional use permit (CUP) that allows for an unlimited number of amplified events, which they argue disrupts their right to quiet enjoyment in their homes.

Camp Shadhan, a local resident and former design review board member, emphasized that the appeal is not against the Landmarks Society's mission but rather seeks to establish reasonable limits on the number of amplified events. He highlighted that all seven immediate neighbors support the appeal, expressing concerns over noise levels that exceed the permitted 60 decibels during events, which they have documented using personal decibel meters.

Amanda Stevens, another resident, echoed these concerns, stating that the noise from weddings often exceeds acceptable levels and disrupts the neighborhood. She called for a maximum of 14 weddings per season, spaced every other week, to allow residents to enjoy their homes without constant disturbances.

In response, Mark Freyberg, vice president of the Landmarks Society, defended the organization’s operations, stating that the center has been hosting events for decades without significant complaints until recently. He argued that the amplified music is essential for outdoor weddings and that the organization has made efforts to address noise concerns, including reducing the end time for music and expanding neighborhood notifications.

The council is now faced with the challenge of balancing the interests of the Landmarks Society, which contributes to local tourism and community events, with the rights of residents seeking peace in their homes. The planning commission's decision to allow moderately amplified music with a 60-decibel limit is set for review in November, and the council will need to consider the residents' appeal and the Landmarks Society's operational needs in their upcoming discussions.