Holly residents rally against draining Stiffs Mill Pond at county meeting

The Oakland County Board Meeting on May 22, 2025, highlighted urgent community concerns regarding the potential draining of Stiffs Mill Pond in Holly, Michigan. Residents voiced their passionate pleas to the county commissioners, emphasizing the ecological, economic, and social ramifications of such a decision.

Jack Stoffer, a local resident, opened the discussion by stressing the pond's vital role in maintaining the unique character of Holly. He described the diverse wildlife that thrives in and around the pond, including threatened species like the trumpeter swan. Stoffer argued that the pond not only enhances the town's natural beauty but also supports local businesses by attracting visitors who enjoy fishing and kayaking.

Christopher Caicos, an 18-year-old resident, shared his personal connection to the pond, recounting how he and his family have invested time and resources into improving the area. He expressed concern that draining the pond would destroy the memories and experiences he has built there, urging the county to consider the long-term impact on the community.

Regina Caicos echoed these sentiments, highlighting the ecological significance of the pond as a habitat for various species, including the federally endangered lake dwarf iris. She warned that draining the pond would have irreversible consequences for the local ecosystem and urged the county to take action to protect this vital resource.

The meeting also addressed the financial implications of the dam's potential removal. Ashley Schuler, a resident from Rose Township, pointed out that many in her community, particularly low-income and elderly residents, would face significant costs if they had to drill new wells due to lowered water tables. She emphasized that this issue extends beyond Holly, affecting multiple townships and communities along the Shiawassee River.

Sherlyn Eberly, another local resident, informed the board that the Michigan Department of Natural Resources has mandated immediate repairs to the dam, warning that failure to comply could lead to litigation. She urged the county to intervene and support the village of Holly in addressing these urgent repairs.

The residents' testimonies painted a vivid picture of the pond's importance, not just as a natural feature but as a cornerstone of community identity and local economy. The board's response to these heartfelt appeals could shape the future of Stiffs Mill Pond and the surrounding areas, highlighting the need for collaborative efforts to preserve this cherished resource for generations to come.