Speakers urge York County Board to rename Magruder Elementary due to Confederate ties

The York County School Board meeting on May 19, 2025, was dominated by passionate calls for the renaming of Magruder Elementary School, a topic that has sparked significant debate within the community. Speakers at the meeting highlighted the historical implications of the school's name, which is linked to Confederate General John Bankhead Magruder, and urged the board to take action.

Barbara Haywood, a former board member, emphasized the need to reconsider the name in light of new historical research. She suggested that the board has a responsibility to acknowledge the complexities of history and proposed renaming the school to Bruton Elementary as a more fitting tribute. "I challenge you not to be afraid of our history, but to truly embrace and acknowledge the good, the bad, and the ugly," she stated.

Danielle Francis echoed these sentiments, arguing that retaining the name Magruder sends a harmful message. She pointed out the importance of creating inclusive environments for students, particularly those facing social challenges. "There is no good argument to retain the name Magruder Elementary," she asserted, urging the board to act decisively.

Samuel Ray also weighed in, noting that if the school were to be named today, it would not honor a Confederate general. He called for the board to reflect on the legacy of the name and its implications for the community. "Choosing not to honor someone is not the same as forgetting them," he said, emphasizing the moral responsibility of the board.

Jordan Lassiter shared a personal perspective, expressing the emotional impact of discovering the school's namesake. He described the name as a "smack in the face" to Black residents and called for change, stating, "It's time for a change."

The meeting also touched on broader issues, with Pam Fuchot criticizing the board's handling of diversity and inclusion policies, linking it to a larger national conversation about civil rights. She urged the board to stand up for justice and equality, framing the renaming of Magruder Elementary as part of a necessary shift towards a more inclusive future.

As the board considers the renaming, the discussions reflect a community grappling with its history and the values it wishes to uphold in its educational institutions. The outcome of this debate could set a significant precedent for how history is honored and taught in York County schools.