The Flagstaff Heritage Preservation Commission convened on May 21, 2025, to discuss the historical significance and evolution of the old City Hall building, a key structure in Flagstaff's civic history. The meeting highlighted the building's transformation from a municipal hub to a commercial space, reflecting broader changes in the city's governance and community needs.

The discussion began with a historical overview of the Flagstaff City Council, tracing its origins from a small group of one to three members in the late 19th century to a more structured council-manager system adopted in 1958. This shift was inspired by Winslow's charter update in 1957 and marked a significant change in local governance. The old City Hall served as the backdrop for this transition, housing various civic departments, including the police and fire services, until their relocations in the 1980s due to space constraints.

Key figures in this history included Mayor Roland Wheeler, who played a pivotal role during the transition to the council-manager system and served for eight years, the longest tenure among the eleven mayors who held office during the building's use as City Hall. The meeting acknowledged Wheeler's contributions, including the establishment of the mayor's role under the new governance structure, and noted that Wheeler Park and the airport's name pay tribute to his service.

The building itself, designed by architect Robert Ottaway Blakely III, reflects the international style of architecture prevalent in the 1950s, characterized by its geometric shapes and minimal ornamentation. The structure has undergone significant remodeling since its civic functions ceased, now accommodating various commercial tenants, including offices and retail spaces.

The commission's analysis also touched on the building's architectural features and historical significance, emphasizing its role in the community's development. The discussion underscored the importance of preserving such structures as they embody the city's heritage and evolution.

As Flagstaff continues to grow, the commission's efforts to document and preserve the history of the old City Hall building serve as a reminder of the city's past and the ongoing need to balance development with heritage conservation. The meeting concluded with a commitment to further explore the building's historical context and its implications for future preservation efforts.