Historic Preservation Commission approves landmark status for Mallory Way cottages in Ojai

The Ojai Planning Commission meeting on May 21, 2025, highlighted significant discussions surrounding the historic preservation of the Mallory Way cottages, a topic that has garnered attention due to its cultural and historical implications for the community. The meeting featured input from members of the Historic Preservation Commission (HPC), who emphasized the importance of preserving the unique character of this site.

A key outcome of the HPC's recent meeting was the recommendation to designate the Mallory Way cottages as a historic landmark. This resolution, known as HPC Resolution 20-51, was passed with a narrow 4 to 3 vote, indicating a divided opinion among commissioners. The landmark designation is crucial as it allows for the potential application of the Mills Act, which provides property tax relief to owners of historic properties in exchange for maintaining their historical integrity. This motion also passed with a 5 to 2 vote, reflecting a strong desire among commissioners to protect the site's historical significance.

Commissioners expressed a collective commitment to preserving the central courtyard of the cottages, which is seen as vital to maintaining the visual and emotional experience of the site. The courtyard's open space is intended to evoke the original motor court feel, ensuring that visitors can appreciate the historical context of the cottages rather than viewing them as just another development. This sentiment was echoed by multiple commissioners, who stressed the importance of retaining the rural character of Ojai.

In addition to the discussions on historic preservation, the meeting also touched on other administrative matters. One attendee raised questions regarding the terminology used in the administrative report, specifically the term "wailing walk," and sought clarification on its relevance to the community. Furthermore, concerns were raised about the lack of recent parking studies and compliance with the dark sky ordinance regarding lighting.

Overall, the meeting underscored the community's commitment to preserving its historical landmarks while addressing contemporary concerns about development and environmental regulations. The next steps will involve the city council's consideration of the HPC's recommendations, which could significantly shape the future of the Mallory Way cottages and their role in Ojai's cultural landscape.