YWCA proposes replacement of historic windows with modern aluminum clad designs

The Design Review Board of Knoxville has approved a significant renovation project aimed at replacing the exterior windows of a historic building, marking a pivotal step in preserving the structure's integrity while modernizing its appearance. The proposed replacement involves installing double-hung aluminum-clad wood windows from the Sierra Pacific Monument Series, designed to replicate the original window profiles and maintain the building's historic character.

During the meeting, it was highlighted that the existing windows, which are a mix of deteriorated wood and steel, have significantly aged and are no longer viable. The new windows will feature a black exterior and simulated divided lights, aligning with the original size and multi-pane patterns. Importantly, the original brick window openings will remain untouched, ensuring the building's historical essence is preserved.

The building, while eligible for the National Register, is not currently listed, allowing for some flexibility in the renovation process. The staff report emphasized that the proposed replacements are compatible with other approved window renovations in the area, particularly in historic districts like Gay Street and the warehouse district.

Margaret Butler from McCarty Wholesale, representing the applicant, expressed enthusiasm for the project, noting that funding has been secured for the window replacement. She clarified that the new windows would not only enhance the building's aesthetic but also qualify for historic tax credits, should the organization choose to pursue them in the future.

The board's decision to approve the project was met with unanimous support, reflecting a collective commitment to balancing historical preservation with modern needs. As the renovation progresses, the community can anticipate a revitalized structure that honors its past while looking forward to the future.