LaGrange community debates Cherry House zoning code changes for runoff protection

During the Oldham County Planning Commission meeting on May 27, 2025, significant discussions centered around the potential rezoning of a property previously occupied by The Cherry House furniture store. The proposal to change the zoning from C-1 to C-4 has raised concerns among local residents, particularly regarding the impact on water quality in nearby Crystal Lake.

Residents voiced their apprehensions about the implications of C-4 zoning, which permits a wider range of businesses, including those that could generate harmful runoff. One resident emphasized the importance of protecting Crystal Lake, stating, "The future of that water quality has to be important for all of us." Concerns were raised about how new developments could affect the lake, which is a vital resource for the community, with over 300 homes relying on its water quality.

Another resident, Jim Allen, highlighted the lack of clarity surrounding potential future land uses under the proposed C-4 zoning. He pointed out that the broad definitions could lead to undesirable businesses, such as a methadone clinic, being established in the area. Allen suggested that the commission should not approve the C-4 zoning as it currently stands and recommended further discussions to clarify land use definitions before making a decision.

Supporters of the rezoning, including Joe Hurley, argued that the current property owners, the White House family, have been good neighbors and are not planning any significant changes to the property. Hurley noted that the family intends to lease the buildings rather than redevelop the site, suggesting that the concerns about runoff may be overstated.

The commission also discussed existing nonconforming uses of the property, which could continue under current regulations despite the proposed zoning changes. This aspect of the discussion highlighted the complexities of zoning laws and the need for careful consideration of how changes might affect the community in the long term.

As the meeting concluded, the commissioners were tasked with weighing the community's concerns against the potential benefits of the proposed zoning change. The outcome of this discussion will play a crucial role in shaping the future of the area and ensuring that the interests of local residents are adequately protected. The commission plans to revisit the topic, allowing for further input from the community and a more thorough examination of the implications of the proposed zoning changes.