Design Review Board approves 3030 And A Half Caroline expansion with conditions

Saratoga Springs' Design Review Commission made significant strides during its meeting on May 28, 2025, approving the expansion of the Caroline Building and initiating discussions on the demolition of a structure at 3/26 Finley Street.

The commission unanimously approved the expansion of the Caroline Building, located at 3030 And A Half Caroline Street. The approval came with conditions requiring the applicant to return for further discussions on window configurations, materials, and additional design details. This decision marks a positive step towards enhancing the architectural landscape of the area.

In a separate discussion, the commission addressed the proposed demolition of an existing structure at 3/26 Finley Street, which is set to be replaced by a three-story residential building and a one-story commercial structure. The commission emphasized the importance of determining the historical and architectural significance of the existing building before proceeding with demolition. The applicant, represented by Reform Architecture, argued that the current structure, an old masonry auto garage in disrepair, holds no significant value.

The commission clarified its role, stating that its focus is solely on the design elements of proposed structures rather than their location. This distinction is crucial as the commission prepares to evaluate the new construction plans in relation to the neighborhood's context.

Community members also participated in the discussion, with one resident raising concerns about potential soil contamination from the previous use of the garage as an auto detail shop. The commission acknowledged these concerns, indicating that soil reclamation may be necessary as part of the demolition process.

As the Design Review Commission moves forward, the outcomes of these discussions will shape the future development of Saratoga Springs, balancing community needs with architectural integrity. The next steps will involve further evaluations of the proposed designs and addressing community concerns regarding environmental impacts.