Sheriff Quattrone unveils Chautauqua County Jail renovation plan with La Bella Associates

During the Chautauqua County Legislature meeting on May 28, 2025, significant discussions centered around the urgent need for a comprehensive analysis and potential renovation of the county jail. Sheriff Quattrone, alongside representatives from La Bella Associates and Justice Planning, presented findings from a detailed study aimed at addressing the deteriorating conditions of the facility, particularly the 1939 section, which has been in operation for over 80 years.

Sheriff Quattrone emphasized the importance of proactive measures to avoid state intervention that could lead to the closure of parts of the jail, which would subsequently escalate renovation costs. He highlighted the necessity of treating both staff and incarcerated individuals with dignity, advocating for improved facilities that align with modern correctional needs and rehabilitation programs. The sheriff noted that a significant percentage of inmates return to their communities, underscoring the importance of preparing them to reintegrate as productive members of society.

The analysis presented by La Bella Associates included a statistical overview of the jail's population trends, revealing a projected decline in the general population of Chautauqua County, yet an uptick in violent crime rates. This paradox raises concerns about future jail capacity and the need for adequate facilities to manage potential increases in inmate numbers.

The study proposed a new facility design accommodating 224 beds, which would replace the outdated sections of the jail. The projected costs for this renovation range from $103 million to $119 million, reflecting a significant increase due to post-COVID construction inflation. The discussions also touched on the implications of housing federal inmates, with a consensus leaning towards focusing solely on the county's population.

Next steps include refining the design and budget estimates, with a focus on integrating the new facility into the existing campus while minimizing disruption. The legislators acknowledged the urgency of addressing these issues, as delays could lead to further complications and increased costs in the future.

Overall, the meeting underscored the critical need for action regarding the county jail's infrastructure, with plans to enhance safety, efficiency, and rehabilitation opportunities for inmates, ultimately benefiting the broader community.