Council debates costly repairs for historic building with structural issues

The City Council of Struthers is grappling with significant structural issues in a historic building, prompting discussions about potential renovations versus new construction. During a recent caucus meeting, council members addressed the discovery of open hearth slag beneath the building, which has caused the floor to lift and raised concerns about the building's long-term safety.

Council members revealed that the problems were only identified about 14 months ago, despite the building being in place for over 20 years. The facilities manager, Dave Foster, conducted an evaluation that uncovered the extent of the damage, leading to urgent discussions about remediation. The proposed solution involves demolishing the existing floor and excavating at least five feet down and out to address the underlying issues, a project that is expected to be both extensive and costly.

The estimated cost for fixing the current building stands at $8 million, while constructing a new facility would require approximately $13.1 million. Council members are weighing these options carefully, considering the financial implications and the potential for selling the existing building to offset costs. However, concerns were raised about the feasibility of selling a building that requires such significant repairs.

While the building is currently deemed structurally sound and usable, council members acknowledged the risks associated with its ongoing use. They emphasized the need for a thorough evaluation and a responsible approach to ensure the safety of visitors and the integrity of the asset. As discussions continue, the council is committed to making informed decisions that prioritize the community's needs and fiscal responsibility.